The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith has recently issued a set of responses to inquiries posed by Cardinal Dominik Duka on behalf of the Czech Bishops Conference. These inquiries revolved around the proper interpretation of Pope Francis's Apostolic Exhortation, Amoris Laetitia.
Amoris Laetitia, which was published by Pope Francis, introduces the possibility of granting access to the sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist in specific cases where "limitations that mitigate responsibility and guilt" exist.
The Dicastery's responses, available on their website, address questions regarding the administration of these sacraments to divorced individuals in new unions. These questions were submitted by Cardinal Duka in July, emphasizing the need for pastoral accompaniment as a form of "charity" and a means of following the path of "mercy and integration" in accordance with Jesus's teachings.
The document highlights that this process of accompaniment doesn't solely culminate in sacramental access but can also lead to other forms of integration into the Church, such as greater community participation, involvement in prayer groups, or engagement in various church services.
Crucially, the responses underline that this process is a form of "personal and pastoral discernment," as outlined in Amoris Laetitia, rather than the granting of "permissions" for sacramental access. Pope Francis's document builds upon the teachings of previous Popes, recognizing the possibility of divorced individuals in new unions accessing the Eucharist, provided they commit to living in full continence or as friends, as proposed by John Paul II and Benedict XVI. However, it acknowledges the challenges in practicing full continence and allows for the sacrament of Reconciliation in certain cases after adequate discernment.
Furthermore, the Dicastery emphasizes that Amoris Laetitia constitutes a document of the ordinary pontifical magisterium, encouraging all to engage with its teachings. Priests are tasked with accompanying individuals on the path of discernment, and it may be desirable for diocesan ordinaries to establish criteria aligned with Church teachings to aid priests in this process.
Addressing the question of who should evaluate the circumstances of these couples, the Dicastery emphasizes the role of pastoral accompaniment and the responsibility of each individual to stand before God, guided by a priest and Church teachings, to assess their conscience and discern the possibility of sacramental access.
In cases where a declaration of nullity is feasible, the ecclesiastical tribunal plays a role in the discernment process. However, in more complex situations where such a declaration is not possible, a path of discernment that fosters a personal encounter with Jesus Christ through the Sacraments may be pursued.
Ultimately, this process of individual discernment calls on divorced and remarried individuals to reflect on their responsibilities and actions, particularly regarding their children, the abandoned partner, and the impact of their new relationship on the family and the faithful community. The Dicastery's responses affirm the importance of this pastoral approach as a means of integrating individuals into the life of the Church while adhering to its teachings.