New Delhi: India's nationwide voter verification exercise is facing growing criticism following the exclusion of millions of names from electoral rolls, raising concerns about voting rights, political neutrality and the independence of the country's Election Commission.
The Special Intensive Revision (SIR), conducted by the Election Commission of India (ECI), is intended to update electoral registers and ensure that only eligible citizens remain on the lists. However, opposition parties and civil society groups have questioned how the exercise is being carried out, warning that eligible voters could lose their opportunity to participate in elections because of administrative errors or difficulties providing the required documents.
Approximately 130 million names were excluded from draft electoral rolls during the nationwide exercise. However, this figure does not represent the number of people permanently removed from the final lists, as affected voters have opportunities to challenge their exclusion and seek reinstatement.
The exercise began in Bihar ahead of the state's 2025 elections before being extended to other parts of India. In Bihar, approximately 6.5 million names were excluded from the initial draft electoral roll. West Bengal has also experienced significant changes, with around nine million names removed from its electoral lists.
Opposition parties have accused Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar of failing to ensure the political neutrality of the electoral process. They allege that the verification exercise could favour Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), particularly in states where elections are approaching.
The BJP and the Election Commission have rejected allegations of political manipulation. The commission maintains that the exercise is a legitimate administrative process intended to improve the accuracy of electoral rolls and prevent ineligible registrations.
The controversy has also triggered protests across several parts of India. Opposition leaders, including Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, have criticised the exercise and demanded greater accountability from the Election Commission. Youth groups and civil society organisations have also raised concerns about the possible exclusion of poorer communities and people who face difficulties providing the required documents.
A separate analysis by the Kolkata based Sabar Institute has drawn attention to the impact of the exercise on Muslim communities in West Bengal. The analysis found that Muslims accounted for approximately 70 per cent of the 2.7 million names removed after a closer review of the electoral rolls. Muslims make up around 27 per cent of the state's population.
The figures have raised questions about whether the verification process has disproportionately affected minority communities. However, the findings alone do not establish that the removals were discriminatory or that every affected person was eligible to remain on the electoral lists.
A separate investigation has documented cases involving Muslim families whose relatives faced detention, deportation or questioning over their citizenship after their names disappeared from electoral rolls.
One case involved 38 year old Sahida Fakir, who was detained in Mumbai on July 19, 2026, and subsequently deported to Bangladesh. Fakir said plainclothes officers seized her mobile phone, which contained copies of her identity documents, and that she was not given an opportunity to present them. Her family has challenged the deportation in India's Supreme Court, maintaining that she is an Indian citizen. Her parents and grandparents also appeared on electoral rolls dating back to India's first national election in 1952.
Another case involved Nasiruddin Sheikh, a utensil hawker who described being detained in Chhattisgarh after his name disappeared from electoral rolls. He said some detainees were released after authorities found their names on revised lists, while others remained in custody for longer.
The issue has also drawn attention to statements by senior government officials. Union Home Minister Amit Shah said at a rally in Haryana on November 5 that the government was determined to identify infiltrators, remove them from electoral rolls and expel them from the country.
However, removal from an electoral roll does not automatically establish that an individual is a foreign national. Electoral registration and the determination of citizenship involve separate legal procedures.
The Supreme Court of India has also examined the legality of the voter revision exercise. In a judgment delivered on May 27, 2026, the court upheld the Election Commission's authority to conduct the Special Intensive Revision in Bihar. However, it emphasised procedural safeguards, including informing affected voters about their exclusion and providing opportunities to challenge decisions through a fair hearing.
The court also clarified that Aadhaar could be accepted as an additional identity document but could not, by itself, establish Indian citizenship.
The Supreme Court has subsequently questioned whether some eligibility notices were generated automatically without individual human review. This has raised concerns about the accuracy of the verification process and whether affected voters have been given adequate opportunities to respond.
Meanwhile, the Election Commission has announced additional measures to address difficulties faced by voters. These include home visits by Booth Level Officers, assistance centres for vulnerable communities, online hearings in appropriate cases and a review of its digital verification system.
The commission has also said that people whose names were excluded during the revision can apply for inclusion through the continuing electoral roll updating process.
A separate Special Summary Revision is also underway in 17 states and Union Territories. Draft electoral rolls were published on November 13 in 13 states and three Union Territories, while Uttar Pradesh postponed publication until November 17.
Voters in the areas covered by the November 13 publication can submit claims and objections until December 11. In Uttar Pradesh, the deadline is December 16. The final electoral rolls are scheduled to be published on January 4, 2027.
The continuing controversy comes as India prepares for a series of state elections in 2027, making the accuracy and credibility of electoral rolls an important political and administrative issue.
The Election Commission faces the challenge of ensuring that electoral lists are accurate while protecting the rights of eligible citizens. As complaints and legal challenges continue, public confidence in the electoral process will depend on transparent procedures, fair verification and effective opportunities for people to challenge wrongful exclusions.