Jakarta: Indonesia has asked Google to provide a detailed explanation for removing 19,372 YouTube channels linked to coordinated influence operations, raising questions about transparency, online content moderation and freedom of expression. The Ministry of Communication and Digital Affairs made the request following a meeting with representatives of Google Indonesia and YouTube Southeast Asia on November 19. The government wants the company to explain how it identified the channels, what rules they violated and how it determined their links to Indonesia.
The request follows Google's third quarter 2026 Influence Operations Bulletin, published on October 30. The report stated that 19,372 YouTube channels had been terminated between July and September as part of investigations into coordinated influence operations linked to Indonesia. According to the bulletin, the channels were sharing content in Indonesian supporting the country's government and its administration. Some also published material criticising people who opposed or criticised the government.
Google reported removing 6,888 channels in July, 10,134 in August and another 2,350 in September. August recorded the highestnumber of removals during the three month period. Indonesia had the highest number of channel removals among the countries listed in Google's quarterly comparison, ahead of China and Russia. The Indonesian government has questioned whether Google's report provides enough information to explain the nature of the activities and the reasons behind such a large number of removals.
According to the ministry, Google representatives acknowledged during the November 19 meeting that the company's third quarter bulletin did not provide sufficient supporting explanations. Mediodecci Lustarini, a senior official in the ministry's Directorate General of Digital Space Supervision, said the government had requested a written explanation, including examples of the methods and criteria used to identify and take action against the accounts.
The requested information includes Google's detection methods, review procedures and the roles of automated systems and human reviewers. The government also wants to know how the company measures the accuracy of its decisions and whether it can provide information about detection errors. Another concern is how Google determines the geographical origins of content creators and operators behind the networks. The ministry wants to establish whether the accounts were operated by individuals or organisations based in Indonesia or whether their operators were located in other countries.
According to the ministry, Google representatives said YouTube's spam policies had been used as the basis for action against accounts identified as part of coordinated influence operations. However, the company has not publicly explained the specific violations committed by the terminated channels. Google said it routinely disrupts coordinated influence operations as part of its global efforts to protect its platforms, including YouTube. The company also maintained that its policies are enforced regardless of the political viewpoints expressed by users.
Google representatives told the Indonesian ministry that they would need to coordinate with the company's global team that prepares the quarterly bulletin before providing the requested explanations. The ministry said it supports efforts by digital platforms to prevent information manipulation and inauthentic online activities. However, it stressed that large scale content moderation must be transparent, accountable, proportionate and fair.
It also emphasised that freedom of expression must be protected equally for people who support the government and those who criticise it. The ministry warned that a lack of detailed explanations could lead to incorrect conclusions about the people or organisations behind the channels. The issue has emerged amid growing political and economic dissatisfaction under President Prabowo Subianto. A survey by Saiful Mujani Research and Consulting found that Prabowo's approval rating had fallen to 51.1 per cent in July 2026, from 81.2 per cent in November 2025. Public concerns about economic conditions and the government's policies contributed to the decline.
However, Google has not linked the removal of the YouTube channels to Indonesia's domestic political developments or identified the government as the operator of the networks. The company has also not publicly identified the individuals or organisations responsible for the accounts or explained how the operations were funded. The Indonesian ministry has called on Google and YouTube to use their detection capabilities more widely against coordinated networks promoting online gambling and distributing pornographic content.
The government is now awaiting further clarification from Google as it seeks greater accountability in the way major digital platforms identify and remove online accounts. The dispute highlights the growing challenge of balancing efforts to prevent coordinated online manipulation with the need to protect freedom of expression and ensure fair treatment of users.