The Hague: The Rohingya Muslim minority has secured a major legal victory after the International Court of Justice ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the community during the military operations in 2017. The decision marks the first time the court has found a state responsible for committing genocide. However, the ruling has raised hopes of justice without providing an immediate solution for the millions of Rohingya who remain displaced from their homes. The judgment, delivered on Thursday, November 19, marks a significant moment in the long struggle for accountability over the violence that forced hundreds of thousands of Rohingya to flee Myanmar. The court found Myanmar responsible for genocide against the minority during the military operations in northern Rakhine State.
The case was brought by The Gambia in November 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention. The West African country argued that Myanmar had violated its international obligations by failing to prevent and punish acts of genocide against the Rohingya. The court's decision requires Myanmar to investigate suspected perpetrators and prosecute and punish those responsible where warranted. It also ordered the country to take measures to prevent further violations and provide remedies for the damage suffered by the Rohingya.
The ruling includes requirements for restitution, compensation and guarantees against a repetition of the atrocities. These measures include facilitating the safe, voluntary and dignified return of displaced Rohingya to their places of residence, reuniting separated families, restoring lost property and providing physical and psychological rehabilitation. However, the court also rejected The Gambia's claim that Myanmar had violated its obligation to prevent direct and public incitement to genocide by private individuals in northern Rakhine State. This was an important distinction in the court's findings, as it did not accept every allegation presented in the case.
The court did not announce a specific compensation amount. Myanmar must submit a report within two years outlining the restitution measures it has adopted and the compensation proposed where full restitution is not possible. The court will subsequently determine the amount and arrangements for compensation. Myanmar rejected the judgment on Friday, describing it as unfair. Presidential spokeswoman Khine Khine Soe said the decision was not unanimous, with nine judges supporting the ruling and six opposing it. She said the government needed time to examine the lengthy legal documents.
Myanmar has maintained that its 2017 military operations were aimed at insurgents rather than the Rohingya population. Despite the government's rejection, the ICJ judgment is legally binding on Myanmar. The court is the principal judicial body of the United Nations, and its decisions in cases between states are final and cannot be appealed. The ruling does not mean that individual military leaders have been convicted of criminal offences. The case concerns Myanmar's responsibility as a state under international law. The investigation and prosecution of individuals remain separate legal processes.
The question of whether Rohingya refugees can return home remains one of the biggest challenges following the judgment. Myanmar has been experiencing widespread armed conflict since the military coup in February 2021. Fighting between the military and armed groups has further destabilised Rakhine State, where most Rohingya refugees lived before fleeing.
The Arakan Army, an ethnic armed group fighting Myanmar's military, has gained control of large parts of Rakhine State. This creates further difficulties for any future repatriation agreement because Myanmar's central authorities do not control all the areas where refugees would need to return. Any practical return arrangement would also need to address the security and administrative situation in territories controlled by the Arakan Army. The Rohingya continue to face longstanding restrictions on citizenship, movement, education, healthcare and employment. Many have been denied Myanmar citizenship and have experienced discrimination for decades.
Human rights organisations and United Nations agencies have repeatedly warned that conditions for safe, voluntary and dignified repatriation have not been established. Returning refugees need more than permission to cross the border. They require protection from violence, recognition of their rights and opportunities to rebuild their lives. Bangladesh, which hosts the majority of Rohingya refugees, has welcomed the opportunity created by the judgment to increase international pressure on Myanmar.
Around 1.2 million Rohingya refugees are living in Bangladesh, mainly in camps in Cox's Bazar. More than 700,000 people fled across the border during the military crackdown in 2017.
Bangladesh's State Minister for Foreign Affairs, Humaiun Kobir, said the country would work with international agencies to establish conditions for safe repatriation. He suggested that a return process could potentially be arranged within 12 to 18 months, although several obstacles remain. However, Myanmar has not agreed to this proposed timetable, and no formal repatriation arrangement has been announced. The continuing conflict, security concerns and unresolved citizenship issues remain major barriers to the process.
Meanwhile, the humanitarian situation in the refugee camps remains difficult. Many families depend on international assistance for food, shelter, healthcare and other essential needs. The United Nations and its humanitarian partners have also warned about funding shortages. The 2026 humanitarian response plan sought approximately $710.5 million to support refugees and vulnerable communities in Bangladesh, but funding has remained below the required level.
The World Food Programme has warned that continued financial shortages could affect food assistance for refugees in the coming months. The ICJ case represents an important step towards international accountability for the suffering of the Rohingya. It also strengthens the legal pressure on Myanmar to address the consequences of the violence and protect the rights of the Rohingya community.
However, the judgment alone cannot end the conflict, restore citizenship or guarantee the safety of refugees who wish to return. For the Rohingya, the ruling brings long-awaited recognition of the atrocities they suffered. Their hopes of returning home, however, will depend on whether Myanmar and the international community can turn the legal decision into meaningful action, lasting security and equal rights.