The controversy over Waqf land claims in Munambam is causing significant political unrest in Kerala. As concerns rise among the underprivileged residents of Munambam, both the ruling and opposition parties, as well as the government, seem to be avoiding a concrete stance on the issue. In the meantime, online debates and fake news are escalating daily. With the upcoming by-elections approaching, political parties are becoming increasingly cautious to avoid any backlash related to the Munambam issue. The Waqf Act reform discussion is also prominently influencing these debates, making the stance of the government and political parties on Munambam crucial, as it has potential implications for a large vote bank.
While some stakeholders seek a solution that avoids damage to all parties, hardliners remain steadfast in their opinions, frequently voicing their views. P.M. Sadikh Ali Thangal, Kunjalikutty, and other prominent leaders have asserted their support for the people of Munambam and indirectly rejected the Waqf land claims. However, certain groups continue to disagree, with notable dissent coming from minority welfare minister Abdulrahman and other leaders, highlighting internal divisions within the community.
The Kerala Catholic Church has emerged as a strong supporter of Munambam residents, posing a challenge for the opposition. Although BJP-Sangh Parivar leaders have backed the protestors, some claim that the Catholic Church’s stance aligns with BJP’s agenda. Recently, severe allegations have surfaced against the Church from individuals like Anil Muhammad, owner of the YouTube channel “Junction Hack,” who claimed that the Catholic Church possesses 1.7 billion acres of land in India – a claim widely criticized for inaccuracy.
The argument is based on a false report, which estimated the Church's assets in India at 1.7 billion acres valued at only 20,000 crores, equating to a meager Rs. 1,157 per acre. By comparison, the total land managed by the central government amounts to approximately 3.8 million acres, and India’s total agricultural and residential area spans around 510 million acres. Despite such exaggerated claims, many critics have used these allegations to attack the Catholic Church, leading to widespread misinformation and public confusion.
The Church, however, maintains that it has legitimate land holdings primarily dedicated to social and community welfare activities. The Church’s land is predominantly used for schools, hospitals, and various charitable organizations, serving people across India without discrimination.
With nearly 174 dioceses and over 200 religious congregations, the Catholic Church in India operates largely independently within its communities. The Church’s land has historically been used for educational institutions, medical facilities, and charitable organizations, many of which serve millions of Indians regardless of religious affiliation.
The spread of false information and cyber-attacks against the Church reflect a troubling trend where misinformation is readily accepted without verification. This issue underscores the importance of factual reporting and clarity in complex issues like the Munambam Waqf land dispute. The Catholic Church, committed to supporting marginalized communities, continues to stand firm in its decision to support the people of Munambam and uphold their rights amidst such accusations.